Social Media Legislation Proposed by Senator Hawley Highlights Need for Examination of Content's Influence

Social Media Legislation Proposed by Senator Hawley Highlights Need for Examination of Content's Influence

Senator Hawley's Social Media Research Bill: A Double-Edged Sword

The Missouri senator, Josh Hawley, has thrown his hat into the ring with a proposed bill, the Federal Social Media Research Act, focusing on the influence of social media on kids' mental and physical wellbeing. While such research soundsswell, the bill seems to be missing the mark, as it stars to focus on linking heavy use of social media to increased risk of disorders rather than identifying harmful content.

Under the guise of this bill, a $1 million short-term study and a $20 million long-term study would be launched, examining if there's a correlation between excess social media usage and higher rates of suicide, anxiety, depression, eating disorders, ADHD, and gender dysphoria in children. However, the issue lies in pinpointing the problematic content that lurks in the vast and diverse world of social media.

To illustrate the predicament, let's weigh the potential outcomes: if Hawley's assumption proves correct, the study could reveal a link between increased social media use and a host of disorders. However, that doesn't help much, as the sheer magnitude and variety of social media content makes it challenging for politicians or platforms to zero in on the root causes of these issues if they don't know what content is detrimental. Take, for example, a scenario where content promoting disordered eating leads to eating disorders among teens. Are weight loss glamorizations or content showing unhealthy body ideals the real villains?

On the flip side, if the bill's hypothesis turns out to be false, the study will fail to uncover a link between excessive social media use and mental and physical health issues. But just because there's no association doesn't mean minors are immune to the harmful effects of certain content. Researchers from MIT, Cornell, and the University of Chicago have made this abundantly clear in their 2022 paper, showing that problematic content's properties can drastically vary from person to person. It's possible that one user can be negatively affected by a celebrity gossip video while another remains unaffected, or that a user who logs on once a week encounters problematic content compared to another who scrolls daily but only sees educational content.

It's high time for Hawley to rethink the Federal Social Media Research Act and direct it towards studying the impact different types of social media content have on user welfare. Building upon existing research efforts and future studies can explore effective methods for preventing harm. The results could help social media platforms understand how design elements like suggested breaks and autoplay influence users.

In its bid to curb potential harms to children online, Congress should embrace this opportunity to delve deep into the murky waters of social media and its impact instead of settling for vague, unhelpful findings.

Images by Flickr

Insights

• A growing body of research confirms that excessive social media use can lead to increased depressive symptoms, vulnerability in teens with mental health conditions, sleep disturbances, and sedentary behavior, which can contribute to physical health issues like obesity.
• Exposure to negative content can exacerbate feelings of inadequacy and low self-esteem, while supportive content might have a protective effect.
• Future studies should pursue a more nuanced approach to examine the impacts of specific social media content types, taking into account factors like content type, online interactions, and individual vulnerabilities. This research is crucial for understanding the causal relationships between social media use and mental/physical health outcomes.

1. The proposed Federal Social Media Research Act by Senator Hawley seeks to investigate the influence of social media on children's mental and physical wellbeing, focusing on links between excess use and disorders.
2. The bill, if enacted, would fund short-term and long-term studies to explore the connection between social media usage and disorders such as suicide, anxiety, depression, eating disorders, ADHD, and gender dysphoria in children.
3. However, the bill fails to address the need for identifying harmful content on social media, making it challenging to pinpoint the root causes of these issues.
4. For instance, content promoting disordered eating could lead to eating disorders among teens, but it's unclear whether weight loss glamorizations or unhealthy body ideals are the real culprits.
5. If Hawley's assumptions regarding the link between social media use and disorders are correct, the study could potentially reveal a connection, but it might not provide actionable solutions due to the vast variety of social media content.
6. Conversely, if the bill's hypotheses prove false, the study could fail to uncover a link between social media use and health issues, but this wouldn't rule out the harmful effects of specific content for certain users, as suggested by research from MIT, Cornell, and the University of Chicago.

Read also: